American Express Stock Certificate – Issued to & Signed by John Butterfield | 1866

This exceptionally rare American Express stock certificate commemorates a pivotal moment in American business history. Issued to John Butterfield and personally signed by him, this certificate also features signatures from Henry Wells (co-founder of Wells Fargo), James C. Fargo (longtime American Express President for 30 years; brother of founder William G. Fargo), and Alexander Holland (Treasurer; son-in-law of John Butterfield). An extraordinary artifact for collectors, historians, and finance enthusiasts.

American Express was founded in 1850 in Buffalo, NY by Henry Wells, William G. Fargo, and J. W. Butterfield. Two years later, Wells and Fargo launched Wells Fargo & Co., solidifying two of the era’s most iconic American companies. Stock certificates bearing Butterfield’s signature are exceptionally scarce, making this piece a standout addition to any collection.

This certificate was issued to John Butterfield of Utica and carries his signature on the reverse. Henry Wells signed as President, James C. Fargo as Secretary, and Alexander Holland served as Treasurer. The provenance links directly to the founders and notable executives of early American commerce.

American Express Stock Certificate – Signed Memorabilia

• Signatories include: John Butterfield, Henry Wells, James C. Fargo, Alexander Holland
• Historical context: Co-founders Wells, Fargo, and Butterfield; early history of American Express
• Associated figures: William G. Fargo (founder); relations to Wells Fargo lineage

Historical Context & Collectibility

• Rarity: Signatures of Butterfield on American Express stock certificates are exceedingly scarce
• Provenance: Ties to Wells, Fargo, Fargo family, and the Butterfield legacy in American business
• Display value: An authoritative piece for offices, libraries, or private collections

Specifications